Jenny makes an educated guess after seeing a big ol’ diamond in Prince’s clue package.
“I did see that diamond, so it made me think of a baseball diamond,” Jenny says. “Or the engagement ring could be that infamous ring that be took back from J. Lo. I think it’s Alex Rodriguez!”
Jenny isn’t the only panelist with America’s pastime on the brain, however. Prince’s clue package includes a reference to the year 2006, which got some wheels turning.
“When I first started hearing the voice in the performance, I was thinking Enrique [Iglesias],” Robin Thicke says. “But I am on this athlete tip and now that we’re in 2006, could it possibly be the Prince of New York, Derek Jeter?”